myabelle
Member
If I am able to get the aluminum roof off of this camper, is it a good or bad idea to replace it with a different roofing material? Thank you for advice, I'm new here.
Welcome myabelle!
Regarding your question about the roofing material, should you go back with aluminium, or change to something else? You can either keep the metal membrane roof or switch to a newer RV-style membrane. There are pros and cons to consider. It is neither a good nor a bad idea to switch to a different roof membrane, but any option must be understood to ensure a fully watertight, lasting seal. Sealant failure is the most common cause of roof leaks, not the membrane itself.
Depending on the condition of your old roof, it may be repairable if it has minimal damage. Post photos of your old roof's condition, and we can help determine whether it is wise to repair it. The front and rear roof seams join the top pieces of aluminum siding. To save those seams, remove the front and rear siding as a single unit, with the entire roof as a single continuous piece. We have had a few members do just that. They repaired all water-damaged wood, then reinstalled the entire roof, treated the metal seam segments, and applied Henry's Triocool high-solids coating to all surfaces. For the Henrys to work, the metal must be bare or have the original paint, if any remains. Proper preparation must be completed for Henry's to work properly.
That said, removing the entire roof and front and rear sides is doable, but if the roof has issues to start with, others have cut the front and rear siding seams and removed the metal roof. Then, they installed 1/4" exterior glue wood roof plywood and glued a one-piece EPDM rubber or TPO membrane on top.
By going with the 1/4" plywood decking, you will lose a little cargo capacity as the wood adds weight to the camper. Depending on the camper model, the weight may not be significant, but it's worth noting. The 1/4" plywood is still not a direct walk on the roof; you still need to use small plywood sheets on top spanning over at least 2 rafters for servicing, just like you have to with your existing metal roof. You cannot walk directly on your existing roof without the support board.
If the decking increases to 3/8", then you do not need the support pieces of plywood for servicing the roof, but it adds more weight, which means you will give up cargo capacity in the camper, not to overload the camper. Again, pending the model, we can help you assess the weight difference to determine how significant an issue it is for you.
Technically, there is an option for an entire one-piece roof with no seam lines. You will still cut and create new seams in the front and rear siding; however, the roof membrane is one continuous piece of metal. However, I have not purchased one of those membranes and am not sure how expensive they are. In 2000, other brands, including Coachmen, used a long, aluminum membrane, but it was soon replaced with an EPDM rubber roof due to the labor and cost of aluminum. It was one really good roof. I worked on one; the metal can last almost a lifetime, but the caulking will fail just as it can on any modern camper roof, and you'll still end up with leaks.
All the above options use lap sealant (caulk) to seal roof joints and openings, and these sealants require annual maintenance to prevent cracking. The Henry's option I mentioned is one way to address the lap sealant failures, but it comes down to cost and how long you plan to use the camper. The Henry's does cost more. The lap sealant, the cheapest option, can work, but you must inspect and maintain it regularly.
That is the big-picture answer; we can provide more detail on how to implement any of these options, with pictures. Please come back with more questions and what you are trying to accomplish. Please also provide the model number for your 1992 camper.
Hope this helps.
This roof seems to be riveted? It looks like it's in sections maybe?
Hi Rob,
OK, the pics came through, and they really help. As FYI, in case you have not yet found our "Resources" section, we have the 1992 sales brochure that you can download. There is a lot of good info in those brochures about your camper when it was new. When logged in, look at the top of the forum page for a tab labeled RESOURCES. Click the tab, then see Brochures, then scroll to 1992. 1992 has two brochures; your T-1740 shows up in the main brochure, not the one called Saturn trailers. The Saturn label is for new Saturn models that came out, I think, in 1992. You are still welcome to look, but your floor plan does not appear there.
First, regarding this picture and your questions.
This roof pic shows a lot.
![]()
The roof metal is not riveted, but it is seamed (hemmed) together in sections. Each section is approximately 24" wide by the camper's width. I'm not sure about your year; is yours 24", but you will see those seams repeat along the running length of the roof front to back. The seams are full-width (left to right) of the camper. When new, each sheet section was seamed, and sealant was inserted into the seam when the two sections were joined. The seam was folded and ironed (pressure, not heat) to create a watertight joint at each section. The last sections of the roof metal, at each end of the roof, were also seamed to the front and rear siding.
Once all section seams were completed and connected to the front and rear siding, the entire roof metal (membrane) is on big continuous piece. Those metal seams were not intended to separate, allowing the removal of a section for roof wood repair. It is very likely that if you attempt to unfold a section in the middle of the roof to separate it, the metal may be damaged. And then it will be very difficult to recreate a new, leak-proof seam to put it back together. From my background, I do not use the word " impossible", but in this case, the amount of work to lift out one section and then create a brand new section to be seamed in place with the whole thing still on the roof, that will be an undertaking. There are other options.
I can also see that a prior owner coated the roof with "something". I can't determine the brand they used or the preparation they performed before applying the coating. I can see what looks like many small bubbles in the coating, suggesting the coating is not adhering to these bubbles. The bubbles I'm referring to are scattered across the metal roof in no particular pattern and are bigger. I'm guessing the bubbles I'm referring to are 1/4" to 3/8" in diameter, based on the photos. The original roof metal had a pebbled surface 100% across the metal; it was not smooth. Those original pebbled metal had approx. 3/32" to 1/8" dimples stamped into the metal. That textured surface is OK.
It also appears that the roof coating was applied over the caulk at the roof vents and other openings. As long as the caulk is in good condition and not deteriorated, coating over it is appropriate if the coating is designed to bond to the caulk. But if the coating was applied over deteriorated/cracked caulk, that's not a good thing. Close-up photos of the caulking at the roof openings can provide more detail if you want to know.
I agree; you have what appears to be a rotted rafter at a crank-up vent or skylight opening. Not sure what you took out of the hole.
![]()
Now, to address this, what do you do to correct this? I'll start with: yes, that rafter is repairable if you or your helper has the tools and the basics of woodworking knowledge, you want to take on a project this size, and you have the time to do it. The best part is that you have a barn with the camper inside; most folks do not have that, and doing the repair outside is just more complex.
We are here to help you, sort out what works best for you, and how you use your camper.
More on this in the next reply, as I may run out of room in this one reply.
So where does one cut to remove a roof? Cut the seams off in the front and back? The side edges of the roof appear to be bent over the camper's edge. Are they secured under the awning support?