This is what I have so far:
38....(Steve Collins)
45....(Poppy & Nana)
47....(pwb01 & sunlinesheri)
52....(mbart5fan)
??....(heaton)
I do know that each NYS DEC Campground keeps a number of sites as "non-reservable" so even if you decide to attend at the last minute, there will almost certainly be sites available. I can't promise that they'll be exactly where you might want them, but probably not that far away.
There are water spigots at Site 54, across from Site 39, at Site 41, at Site at 43, and at Site 51. As of last fall, none of the spigots have garden hose threads on them so you'll want to remember to pack your "water thief" if you plan on refilling your tank via a hose.
There are men's and ladies lavatories in the center of the loop, easily accessible from several trails around the loop.
There are no electric hookups. Generator hours are 9-11 AM and 4-7 PM.
No power boats allowed on the lake, but it is some of the best paddling I've ever enjoyed.
It only takes about 10- 15 minutes to get down into Old Forge village, and there is a nice grocery store and a drug store right at the base of the hill if you need essentials in a hurry.
There are large shower facilities at the head of A Loop and more were under construction last year, but I can't remember which loop it's in.
Firewood sales have been unreliable in the campground over that past few years. However, there are several good vendors outside the park. We usually go to one guy down on the spouthwest edge of the village who sells by the 1/4 cord as well as smaller units. I can't remember the exact location, but perhaps Poppy & Nana, can help with that.
(New York State is discouraging folks from bringing firewood from home. There is a invasive bug that kills all the ash trees, and it is now within 75 miles of the NY border down in PA. So they want you to use only locally cut firewood.)