Hi Chris,
On the vinegar boilout, I was typing as you were, and it ended up on the prior page. See here if you missed it.
https://www.sunlineclub.com/forums/...ater-heater-maintenance-20786.html#post159776
Now to the water heater fluttering. Your videos help, as we can see and hear the heater fluttering.
There could be a few things doing this, but I'm going to start with what the most probable "might" be from what I see most often. We have two other retired RV techs on the forum who may see or hear something different in your video from their background.
I hear this; you can confirm. When the gas burner works, it works very well. It lights right off and burns clean. This helps tell me the gas supply pressure is somewhat OK for now. When the system goes into "trail for ignition," I hear a clunk of the gas valve opening followed by the igniter sparking, and then whoosh, the burner is up and going. That sequence is what is supposed to happen; you have to listen for the clunk of the gas valve opening and the sparking of the igniter.
Next is when the flame stops. This is harder to hear as the gas solenoid is dropping out, shutting the burner down, and the system has to restart. The two gas valves in series are spring return closed and electric solenoid open. You can hear more clunk when the valve opens and a faint click when it closes. You have to listen to the gas valve to figure this out.
I thought I heard a click of a gas valve closing, and then the flame went out. That is a big thing to listen for and correlate to the flame going out. If the gas valve is closed, that points to the controls shutting down the valve.
Then next, it clunks and starts the igniter, and whoosh off, it goes burning again. The controls told it to restart.
Here is what could be causing this, and it is the first place I would look. Inside the camper is a rocker switch that turns the heater controls on. That switch sends 12 VDC to the control board system and is a run signal. The odds are high that the switch setup is working, but it can be tested with a volt meter if my first what to do fails to solve the problem.
The heater acts as if the run signal is intermittent OR the safety devices are intermittent, shutting it down and then resetting it to allow the run signal to start back up. Due to corrosion outside, my first go-to place is the safety devices intermittently shutting the system down. They reset, and it fires back up as the run signal from the red rocker switch is still on.
Here is where you are going to go looking. This is your heater wiring behind the outside door panel.
There is a white connector at the top left of the black control board. And there are 4 wires on it.
- The green is ground. 12 VDC (-)
- The red is for the gas valve; the board sends + 12VDC to the ECO and gas valve.
- The blue is a gas flame fault light. The board sends 12 VDC + to a little red light on the tank panel for a flame fault.
The brown on the Rev 9 heater, which is what yours is, runs the show. The incoming brown wire starts getting 12 VDC power from the red rocker switch as a run signal to the heater. You can see the brown wire enters the outside of the heater area above the safety relief valve through a grommet. That incoming brown wire (run signal) goes to the little clear plastic tube with what looks like a small resistor inside. That clear tube is a thermal fuse. It will melt open if a fire breaks out in the outside cabinet.
See here for a close-up of the thermal fuse you gave us.
The thermal fuse then plugs into the T stat, which is behind the foam cover. Out of the T stat is a brown wire that runs back to the PC board connector.
Corrosion on the brown wire connections has stopped the whole show before. The thermal fuse has been the most problematic I have found, but any of those connections will shut the heater down. On the PC board, you can unplug the white connector and clean the connector with contact cleaner spray. For the PC board, the spray can help, but if there is tarnish, then use a piece of solid copper wire and rub the PC board to clean it. A solid ground wire out of Romex cable works. A fellow SOC member, Tinstallf, is to thank for the copper wire PC board cleaning.
The other wire spad connections clean them up also. Superfine paper (600 grit) can work then contact cleaner.
The T stat wires terminals are going to pull off hard, real hard. Needle nose pliers on the terminal while wiggling and holding the T stat so as not to pull it apart.
The idea is that corrosion in the brown wire connections creates intermittent connections, and the system's heat can cause the connections to separate and then remake.
If cleaning up the connections does not solve it, you should start with a 12 VDC meter onto the brown wire at the PC board end and the watch if the board loses signal. Then, back into what is causing the problem. They do still sell the thermal fuse and T stat if you break them.
It is possible that the ECO (Emergency Cut Off) thermal disk switch connections (red wire) are also shutting down the gas valve. But try the brown wire first. You can put the volt meter on the gas valve connection, too; if the valve is losing power, then why?
Hope this helps
John